About
That Blocking Diode...
In our industry, we may occasionally see a specification for a battery charger that has a requirement for a
"blocking diode". Sometimes the specification is more vague, with wording like
"The charger shall not discharge the battery during an ac power failure."
This is often interpreted as requiring a blocking diode.
Some History
The blocking diode requirement has been around for a long time.
After World War II, when electronically controlled chargers first started to appear, the favored design was the magnetic amplifier.
The MagAmp, as it is still called, is rugged and reliable.
It also has a hidden "feature:" it cannot produce zero output current, although modern designs can come close.
A common technique to overcome this difficulty was to add "loading" resistors on the output terminals.
The resistors were sized to absorb the minimum current output at the desired operating voltage.
When a MagAmp is used as a battery charger, the loading resistor can add extra load to the battery during an emergency
(e.g. ac power failure). To maximize the battery backup time, manufacturers inserted blocking diodes between the loading resistor and the output terminals of the charger, a simple and effective solution. Eventually, the diode requirement became a de facto law, even for chargers based on other control technologies.
The Downside
You knew there would be one...right? It is easy to see that a blocking diode consumes both dollars and
Watts. It has to be rated to carry the full output current of the charger forever.
In doing so, it wastes energy. In a 50Adc charger, a blocking diode can continually consume 60
Watts or more, about 1% of the total power output. In addition to the cost of the diode, there needs to be a heat sink, mounting considerations, and of course, additional space in the charger enclosure.
A common perception today is that the blocking diode is necessary to prevent discharging the battery in the event of a charger failure.
However, the blocking diode isolates the battery only from the filter capacitors and the rectifier components (SCRs and diodes).
Even the so-called polarity diode is "unprotected" by the blocking diode.
Actually, protection against charger failure is built into the dc output protection (fuse and/or circuit breaker), since a capacitor or SCR failure is catastrophic and produces a short circuit.
As we know, the original purpose was to isolate the loading resistor.
The Upside
SCR type chargers don't need blocking diodes, because they don't need loading resistors.
The load on the battery during an ac power failure consists only of the current necessary to operate alarm circuits and, in the AT series, the main control circuit.
And this current would be present even if a blocking diode were included.
Yes, the SCR/SCRF
Series battery charger does have a blocking diode. This product line was designed "back in the
day", when many more specifications called for a blocking diode. The AT10.1
and AT30 Series charger do not have one. We think our customers appreciate the lower price and higher efficiency.
Long-term reliability is higher, also, since there is one less highly stressed component.
Altitude
And Temperature De-Rating (JD5006-00)
A standard industrial battery charger / rectifier may be operated at any
ambient temperatures (up to 158 °F / 75 °C) or higher with proper
de-rating. Any standard rating may also be operated at any elevation
(up to 10,000 feet / 3,000 meters) with proper de-rating. No battery
charger/rectifier should be operated beyond these limits. For
further details with a de-rating graph, please refer to our Altitude
And Temperature De-Rating Application Note (JD5006-00).
CASM PC Board Adjustment
(JD0036-00)
The
adjustment of the SCR/SCRF Series Combined Alarm Status Monitor (CASM) is a
subject of frequent request. We often are asked to provide user set points for
batteries and loads. Adjustments of the CASM PC Board are documented
in service instruction (JD0036-00).
Float & Equalize Settings
Common customer calls come in concerning the proper Float and Equalize
settings on the charger for their specific battery. Each type of
battery has different float and equalize settings. Consult
your battery manufacturer's documentation for specific values and settings
for your battery type.
The following table contains
suggested values for commonly used batteries.
|
Battery
Cell Type |
Recommended
Float Voltage/cell |
Recommended
Equalize Voltage/cell |
|
Lead
Acid
Types |
Antimony
(1.215 Sp. Gr.) |
2.17 |
2.33 |
| Antimony
(1.250 Sp. Gr.) |
2.20 |
2.33 |
| Selenium
(1.240 Sp. Gr.) |
2.23 |
2.33
- 2.40 |
| Calcium
(1.215 Sp. Gr.) |
2.25 |
2.33 |
| Calcium
(1.250 Sp. Gr.) |
2.29 |
2.33 |
Absorbed/Gelled
Electrolyte*
(sealed Lead-Acid type) |
2.25 |
* |
| Nickel
Cadmium |
1.42 |
1.47 |
* Sealed
Lead-Acid battery types should not be used in ambient temperatures above
95°F/35°C, and should not normally be equalized. Please consult
your battery manufacturer's documentation for specific equalizing
recommendations.
Ground Detection
Issues (JD5032-00)
The most common requests for information from our customers are for ground detection options.
Often when a ground detection alarm activates, the user believes the fault is the alarm setting or limited to the inside of the
battery charger. For your convenienceIf an alarm is activated, the problem is best determined
by measuring the voltage difference between the battery (-) to chassis
ground and the battery (+) to chassis ground. The measurements should be the
same if no other ground detection has been added to the dc bus. This will
often determine severity of the fault.
The best way to troubleshoot the
location is to disconnect sections of the dc system and continue to
measure as above. Switching power supply loads have large capacitors
connected from the dc input and chassis ground, and may have enough leakage
current to cause ground faults. Another common problem is that the
user has a grounded load and the Ground Detection Option is activated all the
time. This may become undesirable. Most Ground Detection
Options can be disabled by reading the user's manual. Battery chargers that charge only a portion of a bank cannot
use ground
detection. This is a rare occurrence, and most often comes in the
form of two (2) 130 Vdc battery chargers
being used to charge a 260 Vdc bank.
For your
convenience, we have codified a handy trouble-shooting guide called Ground
Detection In The Real World (JD5032-00).
Hopefully, this will be a great resource our users of our battery charger
products in lieu of an actual technical
service call.
High/Low Alarm Set Points
Customer calls also come in concerning the set points for high and low alarms.
Set points require application review. The dc load is commonly a
factor for the High alarm setting. The Low set point is determined by
knowing how much time a site has available to respond to correct a problem
if it occurs.
HLVA PC Board Adjustment
(JD5019-00)
The printed circuit board (GK0045-XX) used in the High-Low DC Voltage Alarm is used in many
SCR/SCRF Series battery charger options. Adjustment is tricky
because the circuit has a delay between the time adjustment is reached
on the actual board and the time lamps and relays activate. It is easy to over-adjust the
alarm.
During adjustment of the High alarm,
connect a meter to R10 on the pc board and output (-). The voltage will start
to ramp down from 10 Volts to zero when the proper adjustment has been
reached. Adjust the Low alarm the same way, only move the meter to
R22 on the board. See also service instruction (JD5019-00).
NEMA
/ IP Enclosure Types
Enclosures
used for HindlePower industrial battery chargers meet NEMA Standard
250-1085, and are available for types 1, 4 and 12. An optional
drip shield assembly is also available as an add-on to a standard NEMA-1
type enclosure, making the combined assembly compliant to NEMA-2 (*) type
standards. To determine a general equivalency between NEMA types and
the European IEC 529 "IP" enclosure standard, use the
table below. Remember that there is no exact
correlation between NEMA and the IEC IP system, and you must ensure that
any enclosure for IEC standards meets the requirements outlined in the
second "The IEC IP System" table below.
| IEC
529 |
NEMA
250
Type |
General
Description Of Enclosure |
| IP00 |
1 |
vented top |
| IP20 |
1 |
vented top |
| IP21 |
2* |
vented top with
drip shield |
| IP22 |
12 |
solid top,
gasketed door, side vents |
| IP30 |
1 |
vented top with
bug screening |
| IP31,
IP32 |
12 |
solid top,
gasketed door, side vents |
| IP33 |
4 |
solid top,
gasketed door, side vents |
| IP41,
IP42 |
12 |
solid top,
gasketed door, side vents |
| IP43,
IP44 |
4 |
solid top,
gasketed door, side vents |
| IP5x |
4 |
solid top,
gasketed door, side vents |
The IEC IP System
The
degree of protection afforded by an enclosure is designated by a
four-character code, "IP" followed by a two-digit number.
The meanings of the numbers are defined below. For example, IP21
protects against the ingress of moderately sized solid objects
(approximately ½in / 12.5mm) and dripping water.
| Numeral |
First
Number |
Second
Number |
| 0 |
not
protected |
not
protected |
| 1 |
protects
against solids objects
of 50mm / 1.97in dia. and larger |
protected
against vertically
falling water drops |
| 2 |
as
above, but objects 12.5mm /
0.49in diameter or greater |
as
above, but with enclosure
at 15° angles |
| 3 |
as
above, but objects 2.5mm /
0.10in diameter or greater |
protected
against
spraying water |
| 4 |
as
above, but objects 1.0mm /
0.04in diameter or greater |
protected
against
splashing water |
| 5 |
protected
against dust: ingress not
prevented, but shall not penetrate
in a quantity to interfere with
satisfactory operation or safety |
protected
against
water jets |
| 6 |
dust-tight,
no ingress of dust |
protected
against
powerful water jets |
| 7 |
- n/a
-
|
protected
against temporary
immersion in water |
| 8 |
- n/a
-
|
protected
against continuous
immersion in water |
SCR/SCRF Series Load Sharing
(JA5054-00
/ JD0019-00)
The
SCR/SCRF Series Forced Load Share option (EJ0133-00) requires careful initial setup,
and needs periodic
adjustment. Carefully read our service instruction (JD0019-00), and
use a quality Digital VoltMeter (DVM) for setting up the chargers to load
share. A common problem arises when too little load is connected to the
charger set. Keeping load current the same is difficult when the
current is very small. The SCR/SCRF Series load sharing option is not recommended for such an
application. The AT10.1/AT30 Series Forced Load Sharing option
(EJ5126-##) can accommodate such low load applications. Please see
user instructions (JA5054-00).
We always recommend using our more advanced microprocessor-controlled
batter chargers (AT10.1 / AT30)
in 12, 24, 48, and 130Vdc applications.
UMC Digital DC Meter Irregularity
Some users of the Universal Maintenance Charger (UMC) in its early
configuration experienced some irregularity in the displays of the unit's
low-profile digital dc meters. Corrective action was taken in the form
of a design review. The power supply for the digital meters was
reconfigured and began shipping with all newly-manufactured UMCs as of 12/23/2004.
If you are experiencing any irregularities with your UMC digital dc meters, a
meter power supply upgrade kit is available for free. This kit contains
a revised meter power supply, and installation instructions. Please have
the Serial No. for your UMC handy, and contact our technical service specialist
Rich Fauerbach for
availability.

